I'll go first, I remember when I first got into Tally Hall and by that I mean I literally never heard of them and I was in middle school, I found them through a friend and looked them up, and I was scrolling through images of the members and for some reason remember not thinking they where real people and the men in ties where sort of characters? I kept finding pictures of Rob and Zubin and saying "I ship" and my friend lectured me on why that's incorrect and I genuinely felt so bad 😭
That’s the most Joe Hawley response
Happy cake day! Have some bubble wrap!
such creative 👍
What the flip
whats he on?
like website not drugs
Cinnamon
Maybe insta??? Idk it was a few years ago I don't remember😭😭
cool. also happy cake day!
Silly
Happy cake day- (That's funny tho)
I wasn’t embarrassed but one time I was out at lunch with a friend and got very excited when I noticed the restaurant had natural ketchup instead of regular ketchup.
spits out water Natural Ketchup?
Yeah it tastes like regular ketchup expect there’s no high fructose corn syrup in it. It’s more…natural.
Hmm, does it taste better?
I spent 300 bucks on plushies..
You should give me some 😈
bro bought a single plushie
Gimme
Bro bought two sets of TallyHall plushies
Yohawli stol ma walet😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Holla !!
They jumped me in an alleyway once
So true
They could never waterboard this information out of me
My online footprint just gets worse everyday
It took me so long to realized Miracle Musical had the same band members. I was so confused as to why their fandoms were so intertwined
I thought miracle musical was an actual musical like heathers or hamilton and i was searching clips or a resume and i was like "why can't i find anything? Is it lost media or no one took the time to record at the theaters?" And bro eufbeifjfjf 😭😭😭😭
I wish it was bro 😔
I haven't heard NaT yet
me neither-
I didn't know that the mind electric was a song
what did you think it was???
I thought it was a side project
Len pfp
Cherry crush pfp
really embarrassing, but when I first got into Tally Hall I didn't go for the albums, but instead I went to like a fan compilation of songs from Tally Hall side projects, and I thought all those were not side projects but like actually Tally Hall, so the next time I saw that friend and they asked me what I thought of them, I tried to explain one of the songs I listened to and they were like "the fuck you talking about" so yeah
That's okay I lied about liking the Internet Show even though I had literally never watched it to my online friend before I finally did it
there was this phone number that was supposedly joe and i thought it was real (im rlly gullible) and i was a huge fan of joe so i texted it and they responded and i started sobbing bc of how happy i was
Valid bc if I messaged a number supposedly belonging to Zubin or something I would cry if it replied
When I first got into TH, I genuinely thought they were British.
Same
You get it
buying the last tally hall MMMM vinyl off of amazon.. 😓
it’s not that i bought it, it’s just how much i had spent on it ($200+ USD) 😕
200? Please tell me this was some like original printing or something.
it is, and it was the only one left 😭
not a confession but i went dressed as the concept of & to my local subway once and recreated a gif
sometimes i read disgusting fanfiction of them to remind myself that these are real people. i now have several gross images eternally seared into my brain 😭
(shakespearean suffering ahead)
o! why must the heavens punish me so? for all i long for is a third album; yet the album i seek is never to be found; and the one thing i fear the most is the knowledge of the so-proclaimed "naive", who are in reality the most sinister of them all. o! why must i have to endure such a fandom; and the horrors! the horrors of it all! take me from this world, o musicians divine! even if not physical, i beg thee! i long to listen to that song that i've heard so many times but never truly understood! light & night, the barely-released song! take me away from such a vile, cruel place!
Beautiful. The fanfics scare me tho
I didn’t listen to Crazy food because I hated the intro, now I love the song.
When I first got into tally hall I used to post excessively on my TikTok about my crush on Ross. It wasn’t anything too horrible or sexual just basic simping from a teenage girl but good GOD I didn’t need to post THAT MUCH
You're so brave for admitting this
I sang All of my friends in front of my classroom and had a voice crack like 'How do you fEel-'
I was reading a story in school and one of the characters was called Ross and the first thing I thought was "OMG TALLY HALL REFERENCE"
I thought Joe Hawley was a member of Cojum Dip
Probably offering my blood to a well known fancomic artist in a desperate attempt to keep it going (i was in a really dark place)
hope you're doing better man, that shit is NOT FUN to go through /gen
I thought Tally Hall was one person/I thought only one person sung
the fanart I make Don’t look at my profile.
Cringe
👍
ok PoopholeLicker
Womp womp
that username bro you CANNOT be talking rn 💀
I messaged Joe once. I said some really cringe shit cause I was tired and he responded with 'what the flip'. Honestly my best and worst tally hall moment