Tally Hall returns with the worst setlist imaginable (Day 7)

meme

1/2

It appears Rob may be a creep. A weirdo, possibly. What’s next? Do your worst.

in tallyhallby March7th_simpThe Proud Loud Guy we Adore ❤️

109

97%

8d

BenFitzgeraldPincus

45

Banana Man 🍌

8d

The Whole World And You but Andrew gets sniped

9

have you ever tried natural ketchup? (654 points)

8d

Ain’t no way 💀😭😭😭

BenFitzgeraldPincus

8

Banana Man 🍌

8d

Way

12

8d

At this point they’re all gonna die by the end of the show

BenFitzgeraldPincus

11

Banana Man 🍌

8d

Pretty much. It’s a sacrifice being a tally.

Itchy-Progress7262

4

”I stepped on gum! I stepped on gum! Oh ho ho!!”

8d

Damn 😭😭🔥

3

Andrew 💚

8d

NOOOO 😭

Officialbrandonly

2

5d

When in the song lmao

BenFitzgeraldPincus

2

Banana Man 🍌

5d

Then end after the scream

SaltyCultist691

101

I can be wrong but somehow I always think I'm right

8d

Haiku, but Rob actually writes the Haikus live, so you just have to sit through like 3 hours of him fucking up writing them

32

8d

Be Born but they have babies in ties attempt to preform the song in place of the Tallies.

No-Contribution4021

2

The Proud Loud Guy we Adore ❤️

8d

At first I thought you meant the members had the babies 😭

2

7d

LMFAOO WHY IS THAT SO FUNNY 😭😭 Imagine if Rob, Zubin & Ross's kids joined forces & became Tally Hall 2. Happy Cake Day by the way

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

And if they get anything wrong they unleash the Rob

1

7d

He'll start attacking you with haikus. PS: Dialtown pfp?? Let's fucking goooo

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

He'll cannibalize you just like he did Joe PS: you're the third Dialtown fan I've seen in a non-dialtown subreddit

1

7d

I've heard lots about Dialtown but haven't played it yet (I will soon) so I don't think I qualify as a fan LMAO I'm a DSAF & FNAF fan though

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

Honestly anything counts atp🙏🙏🎅🏿

1

7d

I'm gonna have to play it soon I need as much funny phone head content as possible 😔✊

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

Trust me bro there's LOTS of funny phone head content

20

Suave Fellow 💛

8d

Rotary park but Tally Hall mugs the audience

21

8d

Mucka blucka, but instead of singing, they let out 100 wild chickens into the crowd

No-Contribution4021

28

The Proud Loud Guy we Adore ❤️

8d

Variations on a Cloud but they actually jump and break their legs

Im_not_an_expert_lol

13

Marvin ⚙️ / 139 points total (i think?)

8d

Just Apathy^{accidentally pasted off of my clipboard, but meh} Happy cake day! Have some bubble wrap!

2

8d

HOW DID YOU DO THAT

Im_not_an_expert_lol

3

Marvin ⚙️ / 139 points total (i think?)

8d

You can spoiler text by doing > ! Hdjdjdhdjchcycy ! < Without the excess spaces, like

2

8d

ty!!

2

ONE SECONDARY SMILE!!!!!! 🗣🗣‼️‼️🔥🔥

7d

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

3

8d

The prompt is amazing, happy cake day!

12

ros feddrnamn

8d

the mind electric but joe is fucking dead so there's no singing or guitar

11

❤️I STEPPED ON GUM I STEPPED ON GUM OHOHO❤️

8d

Banana man, but Andrew stabs Ross with a banana in the background

Warm_Entertainer_975

10

8d

Ross becomes a chair. (If you know, you know.)

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

Pilates? Really? I mean, yogas one thing, but..

Itchy-Progress7262

8

”I stepped on gum! I stepped on gum! Oh ho ho!!”

8d

Rotary Park but the thieves show up and beat up Zubin and Joe again on stage

3

ros feddrnamn

8d

was joe not fucking eaten alive?

Itchy-Progress7262

3

”I stepped on gum! I stepped on gum! Oh ho ho!!”

8d

I guess Zubin needs to take all of it then

16

average Labyrinth enjoyer

8d

Labyrinth but Andrew falls offstage and gets lost in the crowd until the 10th song

4

ros feddrnamn

8d

No, they keep looping the song's 2 verses until he gets back

Some1ontheinternt

7

8d

And, but they just say and- and go away

7

Banana Man 🍌

8d

Greener but Joe walks off stage and doesn’t return

6

have you ever tried natural ketchup? (654 points)

8d

Ruler of everything but someone in the crowd has a gun and shot at the roof (probably knocking down lights or something maybe stuck in a time loop you decide)

5

Banana Man 🍌

8d

Ruler of Everything but Ross decides to create an opressive dystopian state and become the ruler of everything

Dangerously_gayclown

10

The Proud Loud Guy we Adore ❤️

8d

Bring Her Along but Joe actually kidnaps a random female audience member using a cartoonishly large sack and brings her onstage and forces her to sing at gunpoint and at the end of the song he drags her off stage and stuffs her in an unmarked white van before he drives off and doesn’t come back for like three more songs

6

⚡️Service of the fee fi fo fum⚡️/ 95 points

8d

Joe died two songs back.

Dangerously_gayclown

4

The Proud Loud Guy we Adore ❤️

8d

Foolish mortal. Are you really of the belief that Sir Hawley will be halted by something so measly as death?

5

8d

Hymn for a scarecrow but they keep repeating “the wind knows” for like a solid three hours

4

Andrew 💚

8d

Banana man, but when Rob says "Do you see banana man?" they just answer "yes" and the song ends

5

8d

dream but all the members instantly fall asleep when the song starts

3

dream sweet in willard!

8d

You but Andrew gets lobotomized

2

Tap Tap Tap

8d

banana man but everyone is on the makeup eating bananas for 1 hour straight (no song played)

2

8d

oh hey that's me

Nicktheman15469

2

8d

Be Born

2

ONE SECONDARY SMILE!!!!!! 🗣🗣‼️‼️🔥🔥

7d

Taken for a Ride but midway through the song a car fricking crashes through the stage and kidnaps part of the audience

ghoulsandfools_

2

7d

Misery Fell but they help Misery back up and the song ends

2

𝕞𝕪 ᏰᏒᎯᎥ𐒐 Ⴙმა ꉔ꒒ꋬ꒐ꂵꏂ꒯ 𝚒𝚝𝚜 𝖌𝖑𝖔𝖗𝖞 𝖔𝖛𝖊𝖗 ოҽ

7d

Spring and a storm but the remaining tallies get struck by lightning

Cautious_Tax_7171

1

8d

Banana Man but Joe is replaced with a banana

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

Joe has been cannibalize by this point. Replace Rob with a banana because he's yellow man

Fun_Upstairs_9293

1

just apathy defender

8d

3rd time, Be Born but sung by Ross and is just chicken noises

1

dream sweet in willard!

8d

Willard but they gaslight us into think it’s it’s Dream Sweet

Puzzleheaded_Okra_74

1

Mean and Green 💚

7d

Ruler of everything but instead of singing they measure everything in the room with a ruler

Temmie_Undertale1

1

7d

The Ballad of Nathan Naimark for 40 minutes straight

1

5d

Just a friend, but it’s just Rob talking about the numerous times he was cuckolded, meanwhile the rest of the band pantomimes the stories that’s Rob is telling