I had reservations when Smite 2 was announced, especially given the ambitious promises made about the game. Here are some of the key claims from the developers compared with my experiences:

1. Game Mechanics and Faithfulness to Original Game:

   • Developer Claim: Smite 2 is intended to be a better version of the original, retaining its essence while improving every aspect.
   • Reality: The game diverges significantly from its predecessor. The introduction of new mechanics, like double the number of teleporters and mandatory use of beads/ward, as well as changes to lane sizes and the addition of hiding grass, makes it feel more like other MOBAs and less like the unique Smite experience we loved.

2. Platform Compatibility and Player Experience:

   • Developer Claim: Designed to offer an excellent experience on keyboard and mouse, controller, or SteamDeck, asserting superiority over other MOBAs in platform versatility.
   • Reality:
     • Controller Play: The increased number of active items requires frequent and complex button presses, making gameplay uncomfortable and straying from the relaxed, couch-friendly MOBA it once was. This complexity alienates many console players who enjoyed the game's more accessible aspects.
     • Accessibility: The game has moved away from being approachable for newcomers, particularly those on consoles who enjoyed it for free.
     • Support for Platforms: Discontinuing support for the Nintendo Switch contradicts the claim of universal platform enhancement.

3. Visuals and Performance:

   • Developer Claim: Leveraging Unreal Engine 5 for immersive next-gen visuals.
   • Reality: While the potential for stunning visuals exists, the actual performance on average PCs and consoles leads to graphical issues like tearing. The graphics, as they currently stand, are jarring and detract from the gameplay experience.

Conclusion: The changes in Smite 2 were presented as minimal and necessary technological evolutions that would include console players and enhance visual appeal. However, the overhaul in gameplay mechanics, the decreased accessibility for console players, and the underwhelming graphical performance suggest a significant departure from these promises. If Smite 2 remains as it is now upon release, I, along with many in my online group, are considering moving on from the game.

This feedback reflects my honest experience and observations. I understand if some may disagree, but addressing these issues is crucial for the community moving forward.