Moderator removed post
People heavily underestimate the strength differences between biological men and biolgical women. It has nothing to do with the brain inside and everything to do with the body itself just being naturally stronger all around.
The woman in a man's body wins.
Woman in man's body, pretty much by default. Men tend to be more vicious in fights (mentally) but I doubt that will make much difference. The size/strength/weight advantage of male body vs female body is huge. Also I think there's decent odds that just having your mind in a different body, will lead to you thinking differently. A lot of our drives and ways of being are determined by hormones and chemicals. So there are good odds that the male mind in a female body, would find themselves thinking/acting more like a woman, and vice versa.
It changes if either of the minds has combat training, but statistically most people have no training whatsoever and most people have never been in a fight. So most likely they are both completely clueless. Size+weight+strength trumps everything in that case.
I disagree. First off this question needs more context coz if it's a man with Timothee Chalamet's body fighting a woman with Ronda Rousey's body, I don't see how the guy could win even without the swop, a woman like Ronda would kick Timothee's ass over and over again. I think it depends on a few criteria coz some women can be more vicious than some men.
Yh there are lots of factors, OP didn't clarify so I'm just assuming statistically average male and female body, and average male and female levels of training.
I think it's better to assume averages when not specified rather than extreme outliers to prove a point.
Fair
Ronda knows how to fight and use her strength. Though Chalamet is quite small, so your point still might stand.
8/10 woman in man body
Only because there's quite a lot of girls that have never had a fight in their life, when they get matched up against someone who can do a basic choke hold could be rough.
There's a ton of men that have never been in a actual fight, especially if we discount a bit of shoving and some wild drunken flailing
Yeah, but if we took 1 man who never was in a fight at all and 1 woman who also wasn't in a fight, man still wins more times than not because of the biological disparity in terms of strength, muscle mass and bones density.
An average man is stronger than an average woman
Yes? We know? Not sure why you thought you had to tell anyone that.
he said that men fighting more is the only reason.
Are you joking or can you not read? If it’s the latter, take another look at their message, but more slowly.
Yeah didnt read it right.
I'm assuming the average body type, size and build for both men and women here?
I will say most women are less comfortable with violence then men, which makes sense as the way we are socialized in regards to physical conflict and our relationship towards violence does differ when it comes to men and women. As terrible as the average person is at fighting, the average man is likely going to be more skilled at it, just because he's more likely to be exposed to it. Not saying there is not women who are comfortable with violence or that aren't damn good fighters, hell I've met plenty of them (nor am I saying the average guy is a violent lunatic who's a skilled fighter.) But on average men are just more competent at it and more comfortable with hurting others.
But when you are much larger and pound per pound stronger, it's a hard bridge to overcome, even with a mentality edge (especially since in reality the average man might be more comfortable with fighting he's still not that comfortable or good at it.) It's closer then I think people would give it credit for but I think the size and strength advantage>brutality advantage here.
assuming it's an equally untrained man and woman in the fight, whoever's in charge of the man's body is gonna win. On average, there's gonna be an innate advantage in strength, stamina, height, reach, pretty much everything for a man than for a woman. Experience would even the odds, somewhat, but I still think generally a man's body is gonna be more effective at fighting than a woman's body will be
If there's a weight difference, (which is often the case because men's body's are often more dense/larger than women's body's) the heavier body will win almost guaranteed. Fighting skill will only really make a difference if we're speaking with a professional level of skill.
Since women can't ever comprehend how it feels to get kicked in the nuts, they wouldn't consider to take precautions to that area, and a man can take advantage of that lack of knowledge and just one shot with a kick to the groin.
Ah yes, the world's best kept secret. No way a woman would know to protect her groin in a fight when in a man's body.
Most women I think know this for basic self defense. Meanwhile idk if a guy would go for this even being nerfed because it's seen as unmanly to do so
I don’t speak for all penis-havers but if somebody’s attacking me, I won’t hesitate to take every advantage I can get. Crush balls, heel of the palm into the eyes, bite off an ear, throat punches. No rules in that situation.
If it’s a consensual fight, I wouldn’t though. That’s fucked up
women dont like getting kicked in the vaj either man
Well statistically more men know how to fight than women. So even if the power output is reduced by being in a womans body that woman will be hella dangerous. Also men have more weaknesses than women...you know. So all the woman needs to do is give a good kick to the groin and he is done for. Thi coupled with the inexperienced "operator" i think the result is clear. Man in womans body wins 8/10
As a martial artist the average man doesn’t know Jack shit
Martial artist lol
I do martial arts and guys show up who have never fought before and fail dramatically they can’t even do a jab
Martial arts 😂
Catch up to the 21st century. Martial arts isn’t crane stance anymore. It includes boxing and wrestling.
Boxers and wrestlers prefer to be called what they are. Martial arts immediately tell you do aikido or something useless.
Again catch up to the 21st century. You’re either Gen X or older, or REALLY young like a preteen or something. In either case you’re ignorant and dare I say a little racist.
You sound upset lol
Not really
Its kyokushin karate. If you know anything about martial arts youll respect that
Ehhh if that’s the only thing you do then there’s nothing to respect lol
you clearly dont know much about martial arts.
good day keyboard warrior.
God gave women physically weaker bodies for a reason.
He fear for his own life.
what?
But that's not always the case tho, context matters coz some women are physically stronger than some men. Not every man looks like Dwayne Johnson.
some women are physically stronger than some men
Yeah, sure there may be some outliers. But at the end of the day, testosterone is a hell of a drug.
woman in man's body. Have you seen women fight, it's brutal, the eye gouging, the scratching, ripping chunks of hair out and biting, nothing is off limits, guys fighting is just 2 blokes rolling around on the floor thinking they know mma moves.
Women grab hair, so it would be a man with man strength grabbing your hair while punching you in the face, the best option would be to go for the nuts
If they are both "default people" without trained fighting experience it would make sense that the man in the women's body would have a better grasp of how to actually hurt another man. Boys wrestle around and slug each other all through childhood, so even without "real fighting experience" we know that a balled fist is how to hurt someone else.
A woman in a man's body would still tend toward slapping, pulling hair or "grabbing and shaking" while yelling, while the man in the woman's body would either punch, kick or otherwise initiate a more damaging attack, especially if the fight is to the death.
Again as a martial artist the average man desbrozadora know Jack shit. And women can punch
4 missing replies
Most likely the woman in a man's body if she's a halfway competent fighter. She'll feel like Captain America after the transformation, while the man will feel like he hasn't eaten in a week.