And he says it is a gift she says it isn't. The judge is going to decide who they believe.
Exactly no proof that it was a gift. But proof that he received money from her
No proof it was a loan either. Neither case is rock solid and being small claims the judge has a ton of latitude to decide who they believe
Exactly judge has all the latitude to decide if he should determine if it was a loan or gift. And in this case with evidence that he received money from her for “car shit” would mostly likely rule in favor as a loan.