So what are everyone's thoughts on Burn My Dread Reload?
I think the issue with the new female singer is that in most of the songs she's trying to imitate the original and it just doesn't sound good because of that
I guess that depends on the song. In When The Moon's Reaching Out Stars I feel like she took entirely different approach and differs from the original singer significantly. Which is good, as she sings in her own style and I love it. The song is on par with the original with a different vibe, but both versions are great.
In Burn My Dread yeah, it feels like she's trying to recreate the same style.
Maybe in trying to appease the people who like or dislike the new singer they thought her attempting to match the original singer would make a good middle ground
Maybe. I guess people who only played Reload will love it anyway, while older fans might dislike it. But it seems you're right on this.