I can’t be the only one who thought this was for Donald

It's okay. I gave a gift to Donald, Sully, Beast and Olaf before figured it out. Was on my way to Anna when my kiddo told me to try Goofy haha.

Goofy is historically clumsy

I made baked beans. Which required unlocking stuff I hadn’t unlocked yet and waiting an hour for the beans to grow. It was Donald’s wanted gift. … 😭

He's known as a lovable clumsy character especially in the How-to series that started in the 1940's...How to Fish...How to Ski etc. Classic Goofy 😊

I had to ask my 5yo, she's like "it's Goofy mommy, it's in his name" and rolled her eyes at me. So sassy!

I wad thinking donald too. He trips ALL THE TIME!!

I did too lol

I did this too, just based off all the times Donald falls down in the game. It didn't occur to me that Goofy would be the one this referred to.

I had to look it up cuz i thought it was Donald too

Noaaahhhhooo that’s Goofy

i got the one "hang out with a tantrum-prone villager for 30 minutes" or however long and i spent like 2 hours with the beast before i even thought of donald. they need to be a tad more specific lol

I thought it was donald, too until I got him gifts and mixing happened. I googled it and saw it was Goofy. I was really annoyed. Luckily Goofy's asks were easy.

Then u must only know donald from the game 😭

My first thought was confusion because I can’t give myself gifts…

Same

I would've guessed Donald right away too.

Omg I thought it was too. Thank you for this post lol

YES! i gave him all three and it was like strange fancy rare fish dishes and i wanted to cry because hes level ten already so i didnt get enything out of it😪

I honestly thought woody with the toy death drop he does when he sees me i was like how is goofy clumsy never seen him fall not once 😂

Kinda laughing though at people saying it should be Donald. He doesn't trip, he throws himself to the ground in a tantrum. That's a purposeful act and not clumsiness.

Totally thought it was Donald!

I totally thought it was Donald at first too. Goofy is historically the clumsy one but after watching Donald trip for a few years it’s easy to forget that haha 

How is that goofy give that one to Donald immediately. He trips and throws a fit every five seconds

I totally did this too. Bro is always tripping over his own feet but he's not the clumsy one lol. Mickey and friends was not my jam as a kid so they're always the last ones I think about in the game. The starpath a couple ago where you had to hang out with a bow-wearing friend? I spent 45 minutes with Belle to realize it didn't tick off anything. Tried Ariel. Nada. Had to google it to be reminded that Minnie wears a bow.

I totally didn't get it right either!

Was def my first thought.

I still think Donald is a lot more clumsy. He is always falling and destroying everything!

I just use the app Dreamlight Guide and turn on Star Path hints - so much time saved on trying to understand what they want us to do or where to find the stuff they want us to find. I thought these tasks where hard to understand for me because I'm autistic and need direct and clear communication to understand it - but I have found this to be a bit hard to understand for non-autistics too 🙈😅

[Image] 

Eh. He's a hothead and breaks things but he's can't out clumsy the goof man

I was a bit too stoned and when the star path asked to spend some time with a fella with MM as their name, I went to Maribel Madrigal instead of Micky 😭

I can see why folks think Donald, especially if they primarily know his antics in game. I grew up devouring Goofy and Donald cartoons, so immediately knew Goofy. If it’d said hang out with the villager with the worst luck, that’d be Donald all the way. 😂

Side note: I asked a 25 yo if she knew who Scrooge McDuck was, and she looked at me blankly and said she had no idea what I was on about. I felt so old.

I got the goofy one, but I was calling myself names when I couldn't work out who the fella known as M.M was you *ing t* *

I mean being clumsy is kinda Goofy’s thing lol

I thought it might be him. But I figured if anything it could possibly be Goofy.

He was my first try, I think I tried two characters before I got the right one!

Yes. I have Donald 3 gifts then looked it up. Because I was like wtf he's always falling everywhere

same! i gave him a gift then checked the request thing to see if it changed (spoiler: it didn’t) so i just googled “clumsy villager dreamlight valley.” i kinda hate these requests bc they’re kinda vague. i wish they had like a hint or something added to it.

I high-key thought it was Olaf

I honestly thought it was Donald too cause he’s always falling in the game! I always know he’s near cause he’s always throwing a fit lol

I gave donald 3 gifts and when I saw nothing happen I was mad. How is goofy the clumsy one when Donald trips on air?

I did too! There’s also one saying to hang out with a villager that throws tantrums. I was unsure if it was Beast or Donald.

this makes me feel so much better lmao thank you

I swore it was Donald too!!!

Because Goofy was always the clumsy one in any kind of movie or series.

I also gave gifts to Donald thinking he was the clumsy one before realising that they probably meant Goofy. But had to think a while before, because didint really remember Goofy being THAT clumsy

I did Donald 1st as he is always falling and then getting mad. I then did Sully as he is always tripping. I then googled it because I was like wtf.

I went Donald then Anna then Olaf and then FINALLY goofy

I was with you as well!! Never thought it was goofy!!

My sister thought it was Donald too. I went straight to Goofy. He’s clumsy in the cartoons so I figured it must be him. 😄 (Love you Goofy!)

Omg thank you for this. I was so confused. I don’t care what anyone says, clumsy goes with Donald. Lol

Ha! I went and gave goofy two gifts and then second guessed myself and I was like oh no is it Donald and had to check if it worked on goofy. Star Paths always mess up my brain.

I totally thought it was Donald. I worked hard to get the items for his gifts, only to be disappointed that it was not him.

I knew it was goofy straight away

I gave Donald 3 gifts without even realizing it wasn’t him. I went through the character list and didn’t see anyone who could be clumsier than the hot headed duck always tripping over his own feet. I ended up googling it, and it directed me to goofy. still doesn’t make sense to me.

You're not. I was positive it was Donald too. lol

I swear I wasted time getting his gifts!

I couldn't think of it, and when I acted my 6 year old she's like it's goofy mom 😂😅 I felt ashamed my daughter figured it out before me

I did the exact same thing lol and then my wife made fun of me because we watch his clumsy shorts all the time

No I 100% thought it was him since he’s falling on his face every five seconds

I did as well 😅!! He’s ALWAYS falling down!

Literally exactly this! I gave him all three gifts and was so confused and upset when they didn’t register. I assumed it was bugged until I looked it up. I don’t think I would have ever guessed it wasn’t Donald had I not looked it up 🤦‍♂️

I thought it was for Olaf but to be honest it should count too since he's also clumsy

Lol I thought it was Donald too. I had to look it up

Omg are you serious I literally can’t believe this I was working so hard to get his favorite gifts yesterday literally had to start another quest to unlock an ingredient 😩😩

How can it not be Donald?? 😂😂😂

When was Donald clumsy?

Ugh yes. I checked the chart right away in case cus I wasn’t about to waste three gifts on Donald for nothing and then I just googled it lol

Donald legit FALLS down! Like that’s his animation… why would it be any other villager? Booooo

Sorry, I knew it was Goofy. Donald doesn't trip & and fall. He has a temper tantrum & throws himself to the ground. Back when I was a kid, Goofy was very obviously clumsy, maybe that's why I knew.

Yeah, I thought of Goofy at first but then thought “They said clumsy VILLAGER” and there’s only one going around falling on his face every other minute.

I was pretty sure they've done this one before, the only way I knew

I had it narrowed down to Donald or Goofy. Luckily, I tried Goofy first and I'm an item hoarder😆

I thought it was either Donald or Goofy.

It feels good to know that I wasn’t the only one! 🫂❤️

I got it was goofy, but I could totally see why you’d think donald!

I thought Donald! Lol and then I remembered about goofy 🤪

Me and my mum both!

We blame Daisy as she mentions he is clumsy… a few months back I would’ve guessed right I think!

Nope. You’re definitely not the only one.

I literally gave Donald all of his favorites for the day and was confused as to why it wasn’t completed. I’m glad I wasn’t the only one!

I tried Donald too thanks to all his in game tripping but when I thought about it after looking it up Goofy made sense given the movies and such... maybe that's an animation update they need, make Goofy actually clumsy somehow like fishing but the line tangles around him or he looses the fish or he tries cooking at a stove and the pot gives off a boom or something from cooking going wrong or other ideas

I e learned to never assume with dreamlight lol the developers are weird sometimes

i thought goofy right away since i know he is the clumsiest of the team mickey as i call them, growing up with goof troops as my fave cartoon, i have a hunch only people who never watched any of hiis cartoons or movies would be the ones who get it wrong

Idk I immediately said goofy.

lol I feel dumb because my first thought was Olaf. Then Donald. Had to search the answer🤦‍♀️

but he’s just having a tantrum lol

Someone never saw the Sport Goofy short in school.

Goofy

How can this be anyone but Goofy?

Goofy came to mind first for me but I could see Donald being the clumsy villager too. Although I think of Donald as more temperamental than clumsy.

I definitely did. It was only after giving Donald two gifts that I saw the task didn't change. Sat there for five minutes trying to figure out who else could possibly fit that description. And then I was like, Oh. Goofy. Of course it's Goofy. 🤦‍♀️

I did the same thing. Ticked me off

I had to google to see if it was Donald or goofy

I immediately ran and gave him his gifts and then I didn’t get a beep boop 😩

In Disney canon, Goofy is VERY clumsy… EXTREMELY so

I thought it was Donald too then I stopped myself 🤣

Yep me but it was goofy

Did anyone read the comics from donald how unlucky he always is compared with his clumsyness but goofy can be also pretty clumsy but donald would be fitting more the character in my opinion

I did this too!!!

[Image] 

If you get the DreamlightGuide app it tells you!

I'm glad I wasn't the only one confused. 😂 I got all three of Donald's favorites and gave them to him before I realized that it didn't work.

I also did this 😂 then secondly thought Goofy

Am I the only one who thought it was woody at first lmao he’s always on the floor (I know it’s intentional but I had a dumb attack idk)

I was not that GOOFY... :)

I got a gift for both Goofy and Donald to see which one it counted for, although I was pretty sure it would be Goofy so I went to him first.

Goofy is the one who has falls because he’s clumsy. You’re not the first one who thought it was Donald though. His falls are temper tantrums 😂

That’s exactly what I thought. The way they say it you would thing the one always falling

I did!

I tried goofy first and it didn’t work?

I asked my husband who it could be and he said Wall-E, but said he originally thought Donald, but then thought he’s more cranky then clumsy lol

Me too!

Sameeeeeee

I tried Donald and then Kristoff (not really sure why him now) before Goofy

I thought it was Donald as well ahah

You aren't haha

I haven’t completed this yet but I saw it yesterday and instantly thought of goofy, I don’t know why cause like you said he doesn’t really present any clumsiness

I thought it was Donald

I always have to Google those descriptions

It’s okay…I almost gave myself an aneurysm trying to figure out who “M.M.” was…

I thought Donald at first too. However, if anyone of you do read the dialogue when completing quests with Goofy or can remember way back when when you did, it did mention him being clumsy with fishing and vacuuming and a few other things in the dialogue in the game. He even mentioned and shared stories of his clumsiness in the quest dialogue too 😆.

Goofy is famously clumsy, but i can se show you'd think that, since Donald trips sometimes and then throws a tantrum

Oh thank god I am not alone 🤣

It’s Goofy!

I did the EXACT same thing! 😅

Sure did lol

Honestly, as novel and cute as the concept was, they should just give us a button to toggle the cryptic clues to off and put it back to the original where it tells you plainly. Some of them are too ambiguous and some players just don't know the details of every character.

I gave him five of his favorite things before I realized I had the wrong one 🙄 🤦🏻‍♀️

Exactly!!

1000% thought it was Donald

100 percent

Yeah this pissed me off

I thought this also

I legit did but then I thought of goofy movie

We all did.

Compared to Goofy?

I definitely thought it was Donald!

Donald is alwaya my first thought, he falls and freaks out multiple times a day

Omg same. It took forever to figure it out. I almost gave up on it 🤣🤣

lol honestly yes first thought it was Donald because of how much he falls but then I thought of goofy in the Disney 100 once upon a studio and I was like oh wait goofy is pretty clumsy 😂

I think EVERYONE did at first.