Because they want to redistribute your wealth, not theirs.
View all comments
inevitably quashed by outside forces
So... its everyone else's fault? That doesnt sound like a super lame excuse to you?
"Why havent you made something with your life?" "Because noone will let me"
Communism is basically an angsty teen with motivation problems if you describe it like that.
Capitalism isnt all voluntary exchanges
Yes, it is. Thats all it is. Private means individual, thats all. An individual who cannot own property is a slave - so the opposite of capitalism is always a variation of slavery.
was violently forced
You cannot "violently force" voluntary trades, it just doesnt work that way. You can violently force socialism and communism, but not capitalism. Capitalism is basically the state of being left alone in peace.
You are still dodging the question and externalizing blame: why has there never been a single successful commune in history ? Every single attempt cannot have been found an extinguished by some magical time traveling commie government force. And the staggeringly obvious motivation and economic problems caused by communes should make it super obvious to you what the real reason is. Communes do not work, and communal ownership is an oxymoron.
I'm not saying its everyone else's fault I'm just saying a socialist society that upholds private property rights and doesnt have some sort of militant organization to defend itself isnt going to be successful which is why I believe socialist movements should be militant and shouldn't respect private property and redistribute it by force if necessary. I will also once again reiterate that you dont have a correct definition of capitalism, you're definition ignores the history and reality of capitalism and is just based on your dog shit ideology's pipedream. I implore you to do some research on the english revolution and the enclosure of the commons.
is why I believe socialist movements should be militant and shouldn't respect private property and redistribute it by force if necessary
Wow, the true colors come out. Apparently you are a full on Nazi. Hopefully thats idle talk and you are not a real subhuman goon who should be shot on sight in self defense.
you're definition ignores the history and reality of capitalism
I think its your definition that is ignoring reality. I'm the one proposing to have a peaceful friendly society called capitalism, while you are proposing a forceful military takeover to install your chosen dictator to oppress and enslave other people.
You should realize you are the bad guy. And trying to redefine voluntary capitalist society as something bad cannot work outside the narrow confines of your head.
I implore you to do some research on the english revolution and the enclosure of the commons.
99% of people used to work on farms, and now 1% or fewer do. Its called technological advancement, and unless you are also an anti-progress goon, you should perhaps do some more research.
dog shit ideology's
Human freedom is not dogshit.
You're dogshit ideology isnt human freedom. It's the subjugation of all people to private enterprises which really isnt anything different then what we have now. You're putting words in my mouth, I dont believe in dictatorship and you dont know what you're talking about, you're a political flat earther who doesnt know anything about history, politics or economics.
You're dogshit ideology isnt human freedom
You are too ignorant to even know what you are saying. My ideology is precisely human freedom.
It's the subjugation of all people to private enterprises
"Private enterprise" means "things individual people do"
A private person is a single individual human. What is so bad about humans? Why do you hate them so much ?
You're putting words in my mouth, I dont believe in dictatorship
Do I have to quote you? You just advocated forceful theft and violent murder.
Do you not even know what your own words mean ?
You keep calling human freedom dogshit too - you are a comic book level scumbag.