Yeah this doesn’t seem like much of an iceberg, it’s just common knowledge for anyone who has spent some time on this sub and on the tallyall archive
Yeah, but what else should I add that is lesser known (preferably to the depths)? I’ve been asking around on the discord and the animo and this is pretty much all I could find.
There not much absolutely messed up content within the tally hall fanbase, nor obscure things that no one knows about. If you have anything in mind I’ll definitely add it.
Yeah I’m not saying it really could go deeper, that’s probably all there is, I was just saying Tally Hall doesn’t seem to have that much of an iceberg. You could add some things like how the band never technically disbanded or the roots cover of mucka blucka
Ok I’ve been thinking more about this and you’re actually missing some stuff. Both demo albums (all three if you count Hawaii Part II part II as one). Also Edu and some older obscure songs like “Maybe in the Night” (which could honestly be at the very bottom lol)
Ah! I thought I added one for all of the side projects but instead I only put “Side projects intended for TH”, so if I ever make an update version I’ll add it. Also, I have a point for all of the demos, it would just take up too much space to list them all.
- you can't say that the meaning of Hawaii Part II is unknown then state that all of Hawaii Part II is about 9/11 (which it is, it's about the unnamed protagonist learning to live after 9/11, eventually joining the navy and drowning at sea (Stranded lullaby)) it contradictory.
- I love the natural ketchup skit
- The "Doc" is full of accusations that are blatantly false
- The controversy about banana man was people being idiots
- The mind electric is about someone receiving the electric chair
- Hey, comprehension amalgamation, i love those guys. thats how i first heard Hawaii Part II
- Yes, joe is most likely at least, schizophrenic
In response to number one, three, four and five these aren’t thing I necessarily believe. They’re just an amalgamation of every theory, controversy, etc. you come across as you get deeper within the fanbase. So, that’s why some things are contradictory, it’s because people have contradicting theories.
I put a small notice about that at the bottom, but it’s okay if you missed it.
I just thought it would be necessary to add some context to some of the entries
Out of the all the icebergs posted here, this is the “Mercator Projector” of them all
What about their 2019 release Just a friend I wouldn’t be surprised if they just drop something like that again
I was thinking about adding that but I was running out of room and didn’t think it was necessary.
What is the YouTube link on the last one?
its a weird black rainbows demo
Why is hidden in the sand so popular? i think it's the most played TH song on spotify
got popular on tik tok
ah ok, thanks
I meant it as both the song and the website. Sorta a double meaning as it was (I believe) the first TH song that blew up on tiktok.
ah, thanks
I’d love to see a video explaining all this! I just discovered the band and they’re so interesting and obscure.
what's Paul Is Dead?
It is a theory among Beetles fans that one of the members (Paul) has been dead and an imposter has replaced him.
Amogus
when the imposter is sus!
YES!
when Paul is sus
Someone on the discord asked me to add it but I misunderstood their request, so uuuh just ignore that it’s there. 😬
Joe Hawley just really likes drug
thanks joseph hawley, red-tied member of the band commonly known as Tally Hall
Joe deserves his own iceberg at this point LOL
I, also, wanted to mention that I didn’t make this iceberg entirely theories or controversies because they’re aren’t enough to do that. At least not enough that I or people I’ve spoken to know about. But if you have any I’d love to add them! Just add a source or a short explanation.
I made this to be more like what you learn about as you go into the tally hall rabbit hole, because that was the best I could do.
So, I hope you understand.
good but doesn't really go to deep into unknown territories [also why did you just link the black rainbows demo :p]
I spoke with a bunch of people to try and find more obscure information but I couldn’t. If you have any more information you’d like to add to the depths I’d love to hear it!
what's comprehension amalgamation and zam 440
The channel comprehension amalgamation uploaded some miracle musical content (https://youtu.be/IX6rLyvppWU and https://youtu.be/NbtsZJXnzFY) I think it might have been some sort of arg but I’m not too sure
There's a full fledge music video for Greener and not just a 45 second clip of Joe dancing to the song?
Yep!
WHERE IS IT
no hes asking where is the actual music video
Okay, but what is the deal with Zam 440?
Btw i didn't listen to OP (sorry OP) and researched the yt link at the bottom of the iceburg. It's just a creepy sounding black rainbows demo :3
1 missing reply
just got into tally hall but I know most up to the third section.