what do u all think?

Just s little over for me but I would definitely eat

A bit over for me but it still looks delicious

It’s medium bordering on medium well.

overdone for my taste

NY strip? That looks tender asf perfect to me

Medium tastes great. Good job.

Thats a hard medium

That is a dead perfect medium if ever I've seen it. I prefer medium rare but my wife would love this one.

It's getting cold?

Medium. Good🔥

Looks delish

Looks yummy

Amazing

Perfect

Tad over done but that’s me

I will eat it all, thank you.

In gordan voice "fuck me"

Lol jk id eat it... It's just a tad over for my liking though.

I’d eat that steak with a smile on my face every single time. But for me maybe touch a touch rarer. But also maybe not.

Looks good. Just a bit over what I would like ideally but I would eat that

I want to eat my phone

You did that 👍🏽

You did that 👍🏽

MMW

Would

Yum

This is the first none raw steak I’ve actually seen on this community, honestly keep it up

If I know anything about the internet, they’ll say it’s super overcooked and like a hockey puck and nasty, it has to look red and still have red juice coming out of it

Stuff it down my throat. It’s a meat throat kinda day.

Perfection in my eyes. Great job

Id monch all that up

Over but smash

Looks great. I’m a medium rare guy but I’ve ate plenty of steaks cooked like this

a tiny over cooked and you cut into it too soon

I would say this is just a bit beyond medium. I don’t like crazy rare but this too far

That’s Perfect 2 me. 😋😋😋🥰😘

It’s medium well. Personally, I’d prefer it not so done but if it was good to you that’s all that matters. Congratulations!

Over.

Gimme

Over cook

What's the deal with people cutting their steak into slices?

Honestly bro, you shouldn't eat it. Just give it to me. I'll take that off your hands.

Looks great.

Medium but still looks amazing

Looks perfect to me. I order my steaks medium

I'd eat

oh that’s perfect for my taste gimme a slice

Looks great

Looks good to me 😋

Medium for sure.

Medium well

Yep this looks perfect

I think I need to taste test it but from here looks perfect 🤩

Medium, perfect for my tastes

Anyone else see a cat?

follow up: wow im surprised by all the feedback, i definitely had a lot of fun reading them and this steak was delicious!! thank u everyone <3

Medium.... Looks good TBH I just don't understand why the FUCK everyone has to cut these up in the board and waste all the juiciness?!!!

It’s over cooked

I think that I'm upset for not being there enjoying it.

Borderline medium well, but it’s okay. Still looks tasty

Medium well.

Overcooked but nice first try. Enjoy :)

If r/steak is saying it’s a bit overdone, you definitely did a good job 👍

Yup it's steak

A little overcooked for my taste but I'd still eat it \m/

I think you need to have me over for dinner!

Overcooked for my liking, but looks like a perfect medium will a good crust. Nicely done!!

Looks good to me. Only time I ever judge is when someone wants well done. I prefer rare or medium rare myself.

Medium well and with a bit wider of a gray band then could be had with more care. Looks like it was cooked pretty gently though, which keeps it juicier than most medium well steaks but unfortunately that also negatively affected the sear, which looks average at best.

If doing a reverse sear method, which is recommended when grilling thicker steak cuts like NY Strip, switch from low heat to high heat at a lower temperature, more like 110. This will help keep from going over temperature by so much, while still leaving plenty of time to get a solid all-over sear. Once on high heat, make sure to flip it every minute or less to minimize the gray band.

This is the only steak on here i seen thats cooked right every one says medium rare then they shi come out like🥩

nice medium well, would personally lean more to the medium-rare, but this still looks excellent. gf would call this 'still too raw'

This is medium.

Medium .. overdone

Looks delicious and cooked perfectly

You need to learn how to cook meat