Both movies came out in 2006. Both movies feature magicians and offer a drama/thriller set in the same timeframe.

My friend and I often debate these movies and want to know your thoughts! Which one do you like better?

Extra points. Who would win based on their character and performance:

Best Male Lead: Edward Norton or Christopher Bale

Best Women Lead: Scarlett Johansson or Jessica Biel

Best Supporting: Hugh Jackman vs Paul Giamatti