1.5% of Players make the hall of fame. If you applied this % to the total players in the hall, 4 players would be in the Super Hall of Fame. Who would you pick to be those 4 players?
Cobb's reputation off-field is pretty crap and I think that shades takes of his on-field worthiness for quite a few people. It's like OJ Simpson and all-time running backs in football.
Most of the Cobb stuff was made up by a dude who didn't like him and wrote his biography. The reputation has changed. Dude wasn't particularly racist for his time, kinda just the regular amount for a white dude back then in America.