1/4
For my fans who have seen both The Vampire Diaries and Supernatural, who do you think would: A. Win in a fight? B. Was just more entertaining/ better antagonist overall?
Who’s coming out on top- Soulless Sam or No Humanity Stephen?
Sams killed monsters way more powerful than Stephan
yes 100%. i was just logically thinking since he probably would not expect a vamp to have superspeed like that. but rethinking it, i do agree sam would win. especially him and dean together, they make the best team and could take on anything and anyone.
Yea because of plot armor lol Stefan would rip his head off or heart out before he could even think to do something
But asking in a vampire diaries sub only gets you biased answers you see.
That’s so true but I also know some of the fans have seen both shows!
I would’ve tried to objectively answer that question but I’m only on season 3 of supernatural so I’m yet to see soulless Sam
Got about three more seasons (also sorry for spoiling 😞)
Nws lol I’m used to accidentally getting spoilers for older shows with many seasons.
But he's also gets ragdolled by beings much weaker than Stefan. I'm actually watching Supernatural as I type this, and a monster of the week who is much weaker than the Salvatores is giving both Sam and Dean the business lol.
Sam and Dean true power lies in their prep, knowledge, and resources. You give them time to think of a plan, I'm betting on them more often than not. But they do lose quite a bit when a monster catches them off guard, usually due to the monster being stronger and faster.
If it's a random encounter, Stefan wins. The massive speed and strength difference will be too much for a Sam who wasn't prepped for that.
But give soulless Sam prep, especially considering he doesn't have a conscious and will do whatever it takes to win, then yeah, I'm betting on Sam in that scenario.
Why is it so funny to me when people call him Stephen 😭
Sorry I can never remember the right way to spell it shehshe
Don't apologise! Its funny
Don’t worry I’ve made that mistake before. A few times.
It’s the Kai effect, lol.
Sam. He's killed a lot more powerful monsters than Stefan. Plus, if he died someone would just bring him back. (And Dean would be apoplectic so I don't see this ending well for Stefan either way lol)
Soulless Sam was still a very good hunter and he didn’t need to sleep. Im sure if he was allowed to prepare for Stefan he’d win. If not stefan would win.
No humanity in TVD doesn't mean no emotions. Soulless Sam had no emotions, felt no pain and didn't seem to need to rest or recuperate. Even Cas was a bit concerned when Sam told him to work out what was going on or he'd hunt him down, and he doesn't sleep. And there ZERO chance Stefan could beat Castiel.
NH Stefan likes punishing people, he's a sadist. So that'd give Sam enough time to work it out. I vote Sam.
Now if we were talking Ripper Stefan, we'll I'd give that to him.
No Humanity Stefan wins. "Soulless" Sam didn't have any powers.
Now if we're talking about Soulless Sam hopped up on Demon Blood, then we have a different fight.
Would pay to see this death match over 8 episodes.
ME TOO
Sam doesn't need powers to win? Its almost as if he's killed hundreds of monster more powerful than him, Stefan can't even actually fight he gets his ass whooped easily
Ohh I like this take! I think I’ll edit the post to include strengths/ weaknesses
The question shouldn’t be soulless Sam or whatever, it should be Sam with Chuck’s plot armor or not. With plot armor, Sam easily wins. Without it, Stefan would stand a chance (but Sam still kills things way scarier than a regular old vampire, so it’s sort of a toss up)
Someone mentioned Sam being on demon blood and honestly that would probably give him a better advantage!
Who’s soulless Sam?
He’s an alter ego of sorts for the character Sam Winchester in the show Supernatural
Ohh ok thanks, I wanted to watch that show
You should! Seasons 1-5 were good, however this Sam is in season 6
It’s been a while since I watched spn but I think Stefan could take soulless Sam unless Sam had time to prepare very well.
Lucifer!Sam, that would be another story. Stefan would not win that one
Forget about a fight- you just made a recipe for Best Friends.
Soulles sam was an absolute physco of a brilliant person. But stephan is very experienced in being a vampire and how to hide it, so my guess would be stephan rip off his head way before than sam understanding the situation and making a plan.
Stefan still has super speed, super strength, and compulsion, as well as having that RIPPAH in him. Sam is just a dick…
It’s not even close
Agreed! I watched supernatural only 3 season before it gone in total absurd after that I've seen some later season's only in cuts while my mom watched it, not my thing, but isn't it's a 2 universe's with completely different power scales? I feel like most of the supernatural things from TVD if we talking about them being without budget shortage on sgi - gonna destroy everyone in supernatural universe. Sry for my eng
Absolutely. Completely different worlds and powers.
soulless sam soulless sam soulless sam
Sam would win if hes hunting and is prepared to take on a vampire after finding the bodies but if its an actual death match thebln Stefan wins. Although Sam might not succeed at killing Stefan as Stefan would be immune to deadmans blood since vampires in TVD have different weaknesses so Sam wouldn't be prepared for that and no lore on the TVD vampires then Stefan wins. However if Sam knew the rules about tvd vampire weaknesses from their universe then Sam would certainly drive a stake through Stefans heart.
Ripper Stefan is wins over soulless Sam but it would be a super tough fight and I feel like Stefan would win by luck bc Sam makes a mistake somewhere
Not to be dramatic or anything but ripahhh would’ve ripped into Sam right away.
I think Sam would win, because his plot armor is just a hell of a lot stronger than Stefans.
I don’t care about the fight I’m immediately siding with Stefan
Why do people keep spelling it as Stephen lol
It’s a common mistake and that’s okay!
Yeah, just noticed it and thought it was a funny mistake, but didn’t mean to bring you down or anything
Stefan would rip sams heart out or his head off before he could even do anything
Sam
Uh who’s Stephen? I see no Stephen here, is he a shape shifter? Or a doppelgänger?
no humanity stefan would win in a fight just cause of the superspeed and strength that older vampires have in tvd lore, compared to how vampires work in supernatural. but i definitely found soulless sam more entertaining and a better antagonist overall. just cause i think supernatural is a much better show. no real reason i think