Worth buying a second bike?

Howdy! We see that you're asking for community input regarding bike choices. To ensure maximum engagement and reply accuracy please make sure you include some of the following information in your post.FAILURE TO PROVIDE SOME BASIC INFORMATION LISTED BELOW WILL LEAD TO YOUR POST BEING DELETED. HELP THE COMMUNITY HELP YOU.

• The type of riding will you be doing.

• Where you will be riding.

• Your budget (with included currency).

• What you like/didn't like about your current bike.

• Your experience level and future goals.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

You need at least 2 more bikes 😬

I have 8 bikes. I don't think your bank account is going to like my answer..

Writing this before even reading.

Yes. Actually you need one more bike than the current number. Always.

N+1 is always the answer.

DO IT.

Tip: Transition Spur is a good one to look at. I know a few people that got them and they all rave about it.

Definitely a good idea. I think two mountain bikes is the solution and it’s a modern enduro rig and a xc/ short travel trail bike. For suggestions, take a look at the trek top fuel but i’d wait until the new one comes out shortly for the sales on old models or get the new one.

Try a hardtail.

I would get a full suspension XC bike.

N+1 is the formula for bikes

N=current bikes

Didn't even need to read the post - yes, you need another bike. N+1.

Exactly the situation I was in… I now have a Yeti SB130LR and Transition Spur.

I honestly find myself riding the spur more than anything now and when things get a bit rowdier, I throw a leg over the yeti….

The only problem that comes up, is sometimes I need to decide which bike to bring with me on trips now… thankfully I have enough rack space most of the time to bring both 😂

I got Two words for you “steel hard tail”

Second bike is the slippery slope to 4th and 5th bike lol

Yes

For me it was definitely worth it getting a short travel bike to go with my long travel shred sled. It made the easier smoother trails much more fun to ride and could not believe the difference climbing.

U are asking the wrong people, until recently I had 6 bikes… you need a main rig, a backup, a guest bike and a burger bike… at least…

Short answer :Yes Why: Just because you love biking! And why the f not?

Am I late to the party? Buy it.

My sweet spot has been three bikes. XC, fun bike, hard tail. I ride my XC bike more than the other two combined. These days a 120/120 XC ride is super capable on everything but the techiest tech, a big park track, or a long ride on pavement.

Another vote for the Transition Spur. Amazing bike for climbing and not too rough trails. I test rode one and loved it, but ended up with a bike with 130mm of travel bc I only wanted one bike- a Spot Mayhem

A bike can’t live in a garage all on its own. It’ll get lonely.

I have long travel bikes and live in Colorado. I got a Santa Cruz Hightower last week on Friday and did two rides over the weekend. It is now my new favorite bike. It's kind of crazy how nice it rides and just how fast and efficient I feel compared to my other bike (a Kona Process X).

Forbidden Druid clipless

If you use them you never miss the money, if it’s gonna lean against the wall in your garage then don’t bother

I have two mountain bikes a gravel bike and a road bike. My dual suspension bike is a 150 mm travel stump jumper and my other is a “roudy hard tail” a specialized Fuse with a 130mm fork.

Do you own a bass boat and matching truck to pull it? How about a high end hunting lease or cabin with all the accessories that come with that sport? If mountain biking is your thing and you enjoy it as much as you say you do, it’s really not that bad. There are worse hobbies to have. My go to response to the average local outdoorsman where I live is “how much you got in that boat and truck?” It tends to stop the argument fairly quick.

One thing to add is that having a second bike can open up a lot more partner riding experience. Be it a friend or SO that you want to introduce for biking. Most people that I've tried to get into it either didn't have a suitable bike for trails and did not feel ready to buy one yet. Aside from having 2 to choose from you can also invite non-bikers that are interested. It really just comes down to if you can afford it, and if you think having the new bike will benefit you in some ways.

The only problem is not having enough bikes.

I have 4 bikes currently and already eyeing up another frame for my next build. So yes, another bike is always a valid answer.

I just recently went through this, with no experience with a short travel bike. I have a canyon torque, which is amazing going down hill, anything rough, and sending to the moon, but it does suck on 15+ mile days. considered a canyon spectral to stick with brands, but covid has made them a pretty poor specced option for the money. test rode a trek top fuel, one of the bikes ive always wanted, and it felt goofy and knock blocks were a no go. ended up ordering a YT IZZO and i am in love. it pedals so well compared to the enduro bike, but i can still leave the ground when needed (flat landings are rough though), and point the nose downhill as well. but the climbing, the climbing has improved oh so much. my normal rides, only take about half as much out of me as they used to, opening up more options for exploring. My 2 cents, go out and get a short travel all trail bike, and use it for everything its good at. your process wont see as much use but you will be ready for anything

Yes. Always

I would get a FS XC bike and see how you like it. In the spectrum of bicycle types, there is a little overlap between FS XC and Enduro. So depending on the trails you ride, you may find that you don't need an Enduro bike at all.

Or go farther from the Enduro and get a gravel bike. Yeah, it's going to suck on chunky trails, but if you want to crank out miles and miles of dirt road, there isn't much better.

Longer distances with things like rail-to-trail lines? A Gravel Adventure bike could be a good fit and be very different than your existing setup. They are also great fun on tame trails you feel you've already mastered with the full suspension. Something like the Breezer Radar-X or Salsa Fargo would give you a very different and justifiable N+1 bike, while still allowing you to take in on tame singletrack. Rigid steel instead of worrying about maintaining a second full suspension bike.

Otherwise, yeah a full sus XC bike like Scott Spark, Orbear Oiz, Canyon Lux, or Specialized Epic... while still being full sus, is going to give you a different ride than Enduro. Justifiably different? That's up to you and your wallet.

I've justified my N+1 up to 4 as such...

• eCommuter Road/Gravel - Rigid - 38mm slick tires.
• Adventure/Gravel - Rigid - 50mm semi-slick tires.
• eMTB All-Mountain - 160/150 - 2.5" Enduro tires
• DownCounty/Trail - 130/120 - 2.2" XC tires.

My N+1 soul is now full. Any new additions need one of them to exit.

Start with a short travel trail bike, something in the 130-120 travel range. Then you have a good excuse to go for the XC bike later!

Trek has deep discounts on there Top Fuel full suspension XC bike.

I have a gravel bike, a road bike, & an MTB. Really wanting a XC bike now. 😬

Ii was in the exact same boat as you. Started with a 160 enduro bike because I got a great deal on it with a top quality build from a boutique brand. Ride that for a couple of years doing a mix of enduro and xc, but realistically mostly xc.

I made up my mind last year while constantly going up and down to look for something a bit more xc focused that could still rock at descending.

Oh man am I happy I put myself in that financial move. It was worth every penny. My enduro is for sale but it hasn’t sold yet. Either way, still worth it. Do it.

Yes buy 10 ride them with your friends is the best fun you can have !

A friend of mine worked in a bike store and has a habit of building all sorts of bikes. Hard tail, dual sus, single speed you name it. He has 9 now.

It’s nice having a trail/XC bike that’s fast rolling. Fitness and endurance rides are fun when you have the right bike

Look into gravel bikes. I really enjoy mine and it’s comfortable on or off road so I don’t need to get in the car at all. You could even get one with front suspension if you want.

My son and I each have a Process 153 for enduro. I also have a Scott Spark 900 for XC riding, and an old 2010 StumpJumper for riding around town. By all means, add a bike to the quiver!

Super light XC bike is next for you, then next year a super fast gravel bike

If you leave near trails that deserve it, you want at least 2 bikes, a 160-170 bike to smash rocks and a 110-120 bike to smash miles. I’d throw a DJ bike in there for fun.

Same was gonna get an old road or gravel or something to push some miles in. Super steady cardio

Yes I bought a hardtail to compliment my enduro bike. I use it whenever I feel like the enduro is too much bike for the terrain. Saves wear and tear on the enduro and lets me run less aggressive tires.

Kona Hei Hei CR DL. Such an awesome underated / sleeper bike. Plus you stay in The Family.

Ibis Exie. You're welcome.

Me, with 4 bikes in 10 months 😅😅

I personally got an enduro and a hardtail and live near rocky terrain as well. I use the Hardtail which is a $700 bike (Cube Analog 29"), so nothing special, for longer trips which have a lot of climbing. It's just a nice bike for long tours because it's way lighter than my enduro and you can lock the suspention on it which makes climbs easier as well.

I have three bikes. I started on an old giant boulder (like not really a mountain bike. Bought a second bike, hardtail budget XC bike, bringing my number to two. Got a full squish giant stance. Now we're at three.

Got a fat bike (4 bikes)

Then i needed a true trail bike, so i got an enduro (because ... Reasons...). 5 bikes.

My wife said :1 bike no more. So i sold the xc hardtail, sold the fs stance, gave the giant hardtail. Down to two bikes as of 2023.

Now, July 2024, i have 4 bikes. These things multiply.

Transition Spur

Hard tail with a 140 fork.

I have a hardtail bike and a full suspension bike. Always good [and fun] to have more than one option.

I fell in love with my down country bike this last year after having several enduro. Really spiced up my local trails and now my enduro only comes out for park days

I was in a similar situation and bought the second bike. I’m in Colorado and had an xc bike, and started getting uncomfortable on more aggressive trails. I picked up a Hightower and can pretty much ride whatever I want between the two bikes now. The xc bike I have is a pivot mach 4 SL and I would highly highly recommend it due to the comfortable geo, makes it more of a down country rig that can fare well on 90% of trails. Plus, having two bikes is great if ones out of commission.

Jump on pink bike or craigslist and find a "project bike" in the lower travel that you're looking for. Yes, it'll be expensive eventually, but it's easier to justify a used bike and upgrade as you brake stuff.

I've got a 2019 carbon Stumpy and a 2012 carbon tallboy (project)

After covid, used bikes are CHEAP

Hey man, coming from a 1 bike enduro fella that thought he wanted more bikes. I love bikes, I would have 10+ if I could. I currently have an old resto mod, my enduro, and a trail bike. The trail bike recently came brand new from the lbs. I wanted something that pedaled better also. So I bought a slightly lighter and lower travel bike. Long story short, I regret it. The bike was $3700 and wasn’t noticeably better at anything. If you want a long distance full suspension bike, go full xc, and demo or borrow before you buy.

The key is to have so many bikes that the wife doesn’t even notice when you bring a new one home.

I got enduro , trek remedy 9.8 with push industry upgraded rear shock with upgraded brakes and AXS derailuer. My 2nd bike is Mondraker summum carbon team pro down hill

I would need 2 at the very least

LOL! Welcome to being a mountain biker.

I tried the one bike to do it all solution. Back to 2 bikes. Trail bike and a park bike. Eying some other bikes too. I'm betting I could sell my wife's bike (she never rides it and it's hanging on the side of the garage where I park my truck), buy a third bike for myself and put it where her bike was. As long as the new bike has a black frame and some pink decals, I should be good to go.

Personally I love the downcountry/Enduro combo. I'm on a stage race right now with my SB120 and as soon as that's over I have an Enduro with my Megatower. Something like an SB120, rocky mountain Element, Ibis Exie, would be an awesome stablemate for your process. 

Note; the SB120 is on the down end of downcountry, it's heavy and burly for a 130/120 bike.

Xc or light trail bike

Yes get another bike if you can afford it. A lighter xc style bike will be way more fun for longer distances on less aggressive trails.

Correct number of bikes is n+1.

My husband sometimes regrets that he got me into mountain biking, as I now have five bikes.

Fuckkk I might just buy that $300 bmx I've been eyeballing so I can ride with my kids at the skatepark.

After all, some of the components on my mountain bike cost that much or more.

Right guys?!

Take XC bike for a try, and if you want something in between you need to look at trail / all mountain bikes - it have a little bit less travel from Enduro bike. Or try another "trick", switch your tires to lighter casing (XC/trail) - you can drop .5 to 1 kg of weight what will make your bike trail bike weight lol and roll much faster. Suspension setup / propedal / lockout - for uphills.

I give you my own perspective - I was riding Hardtail (150mm) for last 10 years (before had 3 bikes, DH, AM HT and BMX) - I kept my All mountain hardtail as I didn't had enough space for all bikes. The bike suites my well, I have nothing too chunky / rocky and I like to ride my bike everywhere, from XC to Downhill comps, pumptracks and freeride lines. I enjoyed the challenge and cheap maintenance.

Last year I needed an upgrade and had opportunity to try Transition Patrol 160/155 (2017 model) - I was in the market for another hardtail but gave a chance for this machine. And I love it, I switched back tire to Rock Razor (semi-slick) - it pedals well, suspension is full open (I got service and pro tune), I can't bottom it out as my trails are too mellow lol - I do all the same as with my Hardtail with extra softness in the back / longer wheel base.

In the end I see bike as a platform, you take a platform and then mod it to fit your taste - AM bikes have no taste in general, they are stable and balanced - nothing spicy compared to Downhill or XC. But changing tires / suspension setup / cockpit you can change it.

Downhill > Freeride > Enduro > All Mountain > Trail > XC > Gravel > Road

Saw the title, didn't read the text, came here to say yes. Greets!

You only have one bike? Didn’t occur to me that was possible.

I only read the title, but yes, you need another bike. If you’re on a full suspension enduro atm, why not have a go on a hardtail? I went the other way, rode hardtails all my life and recently came into a full suspension enduro. Took ages to get used to it. Gotta say though, a well setup HT is an absolute blast.

If its range you want I would think and e-mtb would be better. I dont think getting a XC bike would give you that much more range over an enduro bike to justify buying a whole other bike.

Obviously yes, you need another bike. But, do you need an XC? Maybe not. A good all trail 150 would be easier on climbs and “less bike” on longer distances.

Bikes are always n+1

However, I know quite a few people that seem to get some of the new light weight e-bikes and just do everything on it. Extender battery for longer missions.