Reddit removed post for content policy violations
I once saw an antisemitic screed using our long history of expulsions as proof that we weren’t so much discriminated against as that we cause trouble wherever we go… kind of an interesting inversion. Like telling a robbery victim that the robbery is proof they were flaunting their wealth or something. Antisemites are nothing if not imaginative!
Yep, somebody literally told me this on Reddit. They used the analogy "if a tenant gets kicked out of 1 house, maybe it's not their fault, but if they get kicked out of 1000 houses, maybe it's their fault" which, of course, is the saddest kind of ignorance and antisemitism, they could say the same thing about Kurds, Druze, Roma, people with disabilities, homosexuals. It really is an inexcusable level of ignorance, and sad to see parroted.
It has a sort of superficial explanatory logic to it. One interesting thing about antisemitism is that it isn’t a simple dislike of a group like other “isms”, it also claims the ability to be a worldview and explain the root cause of social ills. I guess that’s why they call it the socialism of fools.
I don't think there's any logic there. It's the "look at what she was wearing" defense that rapists use.
While not right (morally) - you could then point out all the expulsions Palestinians have endured throughout the Arab world.... Which should shut them up...
That's literally what this document was compiled for, to prove we can never be integrated into society and thus should be cleansed from the world. It's from a neo Nazi website. But it's still very interesting to keep as a reference, and previous discussions of this document on Reddit have noted it still has missing expulsions.
I was gonna say that I don't think the Lev Tahor in 2014 isn't a good example but it makes sense that neo-Nazis would include it.
Oh yeah, the ol’ “well maybe if so many countries expelled you and murdered your people, you’re the problem”
Nailed it.
Yes! The “109-and-counting” trope.
They’d often refer to the US as the “110th.”
One thing you can say to these schlubs is, “If a cake is made from a mold, don’t be surprised at what the cake looks like.”
IOW, if you create a scenario, don’t be surprised that the results are as expected. Jews were unable to own land—hence no farming—and since we were denied permanence, we took jobs that could be done “on the fly.”
The overlords made us leave. So we left.
This is an extremely common tactic
It's from a neo Nazi website
People should know this. What is their motivation, and how can anything from a neo-Nazi website regarding the Jews be accurate?
I gave it a glance and see this:
"1654 A.D. – New Amsterdam, United States
Jews Expelled by Dutch colonist Peter Stuyvesant"
Except they weren't expelled. Stuyvesant wanted to expel them and he wrote to his boss, the Dutch West India Co. in Amsterdam, requesting permission to expel them. Permission denied. History tells us this: "By 1655 [one year after they were supposedly "expelled"], the Jews of New Amsterdam, supplemented by additional arrivals, had acquired a separate Jewish burial ground and a Torah scroll lent by the Amsterdam synagogue." https://jwa.org/350years/factsheet1654
Using neo-Nazi generated documents for any purpose gives them a degree of "credence" which is not warranted and I think it is wrong to do so. If some Jewish person wishes to compile such a list, please do so. This thread should be deleted.
Agreed
They literally can’t leave us alone for even a second
They’re obsessed
We live rent free in their heads
Beyoncé once said: “you know you that bitch when you cause all this conversation”
It's irritating that most of the reasons are left blank if there isn't a way to blame Jews.
My goodness that’s a freaking long pdf
In 70 AD 1.1 million Jews were killed, and another 97,000 were taken captive by the Romans. Does anyone know what the population was at that time? How many were left behind?
Thanks in advance!
I was wondering the same thing. I skimmed through most of this list and I was just adding up the millions that have been documented to have been murdered throughout the millennia. No wonder our numbers are so small with the millions murdered and millions more forced to convert or abandon their religion. It’s interesting how you see so many people from around the world on the different, genetic subs, showing trace Jewish ancestry. And that’s just recent from the last few hundred years of data points. Especially a lot from Latin America likely linked to the Spanish Inquisition and Jews moving to the New World. I think I once read that 10s of millions of Brazilians have Jewish ancestry or some crazy number like a huge portion of their population like 50M+.
2 missing replies
Your post was removed because it was created by neo-Nazis and the phrasing and inclusion criteria of information in this list is problematic and in fact serves the purposes of those neo-Nazis.
It is important to document this information, but not to share neo-Nazi-written information.