What do you think ? Who did it better or Who would you prefer?
Discuss 🎙️Yo couldn’t recognise him at all And then man went on to play Khillji like it was nothing
Everyone nailed it. Ranbir showed the anger but kept his voice lower, Shahid showed pure anger and Ranveer showed rage and emotions perfectly (they played their character according to the situation).
Exactly how the hell are you supposed to compare this. The context, character, direction, mood everything is different
True they are great actors but have their strengths and weakness also
Agreed for shahid and ranveer.
No one does accents and voice modulations like Ranveer, he’s like a shape shifter whether it’s a Maratha warrior, a con man, a slum dweller, Khilji or Kapil Dev.
But acting wise, Shahid is exceptional! His films with Vishal Bhardwaj are Master classes in acting.
Animal was hyped because of the background score, if you watch the movie without it, the actors are haming and there’s no story.
When did he play a Mughal plunder?
Alauddin is a Turkish Delhi sultan guy, right?
Yeah thats what i thought too
I agree Ranveer acts much better but Khilji wasn't Mughal
okay, i don’t know about his other roles, but here his marathi accent and pronunciation is painfully off. nobody really says “mohor” that way, especially not the natives from old.
Shahid nailed it. But you can't miss Ranveer and that accent 🤌
Ranveer 100%, shahid expression are expected one The kind of face he makes . For ranveer, every movie is like watching a diff actor
Yes!!!
The interesting thing is if you watch it for the first time RK's scene looks better because of the BGM, but if you go by only acting Shahid's scene is the winner.
RABID FANS ARE DOWNVOTING YOU BE CAREFUL!!
When i saw animal this scene stuck out to me not in a good way. Phir yeh shahid ki clip dekhi toh post kiya
Ranveer in Baji Rao
Shahid in Kabir Singh
Ranbir in Rockstar
Ranveer Singh
Ranveer hands down. I couldn’t take my eyes off him when I saw the movie in threatre.
Unpopular opinion: Shahid's delivery feels like he is sayimg a dialogue that he memorized fully but turned out to be way longer than he expected when it was said. So there is a monotonosity that sets in by the end of that line which seems synthetic to me.
Additional hot take: SLB doesn't always get the best out if his actors like people say. Shahid under Vishal Bharadwaj was way more emotive and organic.
Ranveer than shahid
Ranveer handsdown.
Peak Ranveer
Ranveer
Ranbir
Shahid
Sorry but Shahid just wasn’t powerful enough for a king’s role
Ranveer
Bajirao takes the cake man, no question
Ranveer Singh as an actor is on a whole another level man. If only he was a little lowkey with his antics, he could be the next big thing
In this scene, Ranveer>Ranbir>Shahid
Why are these male actors 100x better than the female actresses these days?
Shahid Kapoor for sure.
RS as Bajirao for sure
Ranveer as Bajirao. A complete transformation in voice, mannerisms the walk and his Marathi was good too.
That was just his 8th film.
3>2>1
Ranveer
My roman empire is Ranveer in Gunday. ✅💖✅💖✅💖
Shahid
shahid imo
Welcome to r/BollywoodHotTakes where you can share your opinions — good bad and ugly — about Bollywood stars and movies.
Help keep the sub engaging! Upvote interesting posts
Please try not downvote things you might not agree with. This is a Hot Takes sub. Add comments where you can!
Please do not spam the sub without adding your opinion! We don’t need to know what the headline says. What do you think and why?
Please do not mention other subs!
Keep in mind that
Bans for personally targeting sub members over religious and political posts or comments will be implemented
Any harassment of sub members will lead to ban
Use of abusive language (in any language) will lead to ban
If you post a screenshot of a comment by Reddit or tweet or Instagram users without hiding their names, and the profile owners reach out to the sub, the post will be taken down after verification. So please hide all identifying features before posting.
Let’s be nice to each other.
Being mean to a celebrity does not warrant a report. This is a Hot Takes sub. Make a post or comment of your love for the celeb if you prefer! Point 3 will stand for all posts and comments.
Please do not link to Facebook or Instagram or Twitter or YouTube. Instead post a screenshot or video download of the same.
Do not post advertisements or sponsorships without an opinion.
Happy sharing your Bollywood opinions!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Shahid was AWFUL!
If i had to rate their performances as per these scenes.
Ranveer - 98% Ranbir - 96% Then Shahid 82%
Lmao these are 2 completely different movies… 2 completely different characters and 2 very different tonalities… cannot really compare tbh
Hn tbhi title m 3 diff tarike se puche. Apne hisab se logo ko answer ya opinion dene ke liye but...
Why's no one talking about the intensity in all three of their eyes!?
Shahid kapoor the intensity was awesome
How many of them can express rage w/o shouting & bulging eyes? Trashy acting & they're called "A-listers"!
Shahid, no competition
Kisi ko bhi method acting nahi ati overhyped actors
My two cents:
Ranbir came off too intense in that scene. The scene demanded arrogance and anger, not disturbance. i.e. he was supposed to play over-protective of his sisters, here he seems disturbed and immature. So, directionally correct, but a little too much.
Shahid seems too bouncy, rushed, and less imposing for some reason. Missing the integrity and strength the character warranted.
Ranveer is perfect acting wise, but his marathi accent is painfully off.
I found ranbir's expression in a sense comical and loud. Shahid was ok but i liked his progression in this scene.
Animal was hyped for no reason
Shaid Kapoor, ek number
shahid
Shahid Kapoor 🙌🏽
Everyone except shahid man he wasn't made for that role. He looked small n just not a bigger persona.
Even I got scared of mohar lava
Did ranveer say - chhalaaa, phone lavaaa?
Mohar (stamp)
Shahid
Ranveer and Ranbir.
Ranbir anytime is much more fine
Ranbir
RK
Ranbir any time
Pls don't compare Ranbir Kapoor with some aera gera actor
Ranbir doesn't need heavy prosthetic, evil look, He doesn't need heavy make-up, doesn't need to lock him self
Ranbir Kapoor intensity >>>>>>
👍 ok wont do
Ok Alia Bhatt
For me, the scenes aren't equivalents, but they work, and that's fine. Ranbir is shown to have a younger look here, whereas Ranveer and Shahid both have their adult king type looks. That adds to the thematic elements of the scenes, in my opinion.
From this scene alone, I think they're all equivalent. But when I watch full movies, I feel that Shahid overdoes his angry scenes. I get that some people may get upset as such, but he's like that in every single movie. Ranbir usually portrays his anger really well (he's a great actor, in my opinion). Ranveer.. I find monotonous.
Sorry, not sorry.
Acting 😂 Overacting 😂 Acting Under Process
If we talk about these specific scenes I think Shahid was the winner, but I think RK far exceeds them both in overall spectrum of acting (although a very underutilized potential). Shahid in haidar is by far my favorite shahid and though I do like ranveer but I think he has a long way to go.
3 missing replies
Ranveer as Bajirao was 🤌