The pictures show narrow and wide so cannot have a short -tall preference based on your pictures.
Update;
To clarify and to provide real answer. I would prefer wide and tall numbers, were that an option. But whether barrow or wide numbers, I'd definitely prefer shorter inter numbers marks; I think the long marks a distraction.
The narrower numbers are shorter than the wider numbers. So the preference choice is between either shorter, wider numbers or taller, narrower numbers. There is definitely both a difference in height and a difference in width.
Shorter… looks more modern.. and I have an aversion to art deco it kind of depresses me idk why.. the longer ones remind me of it. Not my thing personally.
You do know that the watch face ain't permanent right? Just try it out and if you don't like it, switch.
But to answer your question, shorter looks nicer imo
I’d say shorter, personally.