There are some important things about this situation that I'm sure many people can acknowledge. There are no screenshots in the document showing Cait actively encouraging harmful behavior, or her engaging in harmful behavior herself. It's difficult to believe that there was not enough time to take and show screenshots that actually prove these claims. Especially since the screenshots shown in the document were of interactions on Discord.
Validating an emotional experience does not require believing unsupported claims about somebody else.
...Also, an account that was created recently doesn't necessarily mean that another account was created previously. And the timing of when an account was created and how active it is has no relevance to the validity of what someone is saying..